I found it to be every bit as good as my first impressions and discovered that the plastic phone holder does a good job. There have been comments about the plastic around the buttons being very flimsy and breaking. I cut the thin, top edge off as I found it easier to use the button - a solution for me - It doesn't in any way compromise the security of the phone. Also, I find the fact that the plastic holder is fixed for only the right hand half of its base (as I suspect it was designed to be) ideal as it allows me to stand the phone on its side on the desk as & when required - another plus for me. I think a previous reviewer complained about there only being room for banknotes if folded - Remember, the case is made to fit the phone, not the banknote!
When I swapped to an iPhone 6S, I removed the 6 (and gave it to my wife) and there were no marks on the phone case. The wallet had protected the phone perfectly.
Three years and still going strong. Highly recommended cases.